Friday, February 11, 2011

The Help

Kathryn Stockett's The Help is well worth reading though I hesitate to worship it like some reviewers have. The tale is thought-provoking, entertaining and it encourages deeper contemplation of the complex racial relationships of Southern women that form a painful and very real chapter of our history. And really, what more do you want from a book than to be entertained and provoked?

The Help follows a wealthy Southern white woman, Skeeter, as she pursues her unusual dream of becoming a journalist. She decides to catch the attention of NYC publishers by writing about the help, the black women who spend their lives attending to the needs of white women. Stockett does an excellent job of portraying both the intense racism of the era and the genuine bonds between white women and their black help. Without being overly preachy, she manages to capture the affection black help had for the kids they nannied and occasionally, for the women they worked for.

The story follows Skeeter as she strives to give black women a voice through her writing (a facet of the story that bothers me a bit, as if black women need a white helper to have a meaningful voice). Skeeter struggles to find women to speak until the Civil Rights Movement heats up and suddenly, black woman want to be heard. And the stories they tell are honest, horrifying, funny and sad. It's incredibly difficult to write a book like this without being callous to one side or the other but Stockett manages to humanize everyone without softening the ugliness, pain or degradation of oppression. It's excellent.

It's also an easy read, great for a lazy rainy afternoon or a few days at the beach.

The Postmistress

I had high hopes for The Postmistress by Sarah Blake and they were utterly destroyed by actually reading the book. There's nothing worse than picking up a hyped piece of literature only to discover that it more closely resembles the giant dump you left in the porcelain pot this morning.

I think the reason I truly detest The Postmistress is that it had so much potential to be great and instead, it fell flat. The story traces the lives of three women--a journalist named Frankie, a doctor's wife named Emma and a postmistress named Iris--in a small town just before the US becomes active in WWII. The plot is clumsily contrived to bring the three women together. Emma arrives in Franklin on the same bus as Iris and starts a great life with her doctor husband. Soon after conceiving her first child, her husband loses a woman in childbirth, is traumatized and decides to go off to London to help victims of the German bombings. He's unaware that Emma is pregnant. While he's there, he meets up with Frankie who witnesses his tragic, meaningless death. Frankie becomes the keeper of a letter for Emma and she eventually decides to got to Franklin to deliver it. In the meantime, the doctor had left Iris with a letter for Emma in case he was killed in London. Iris intercepts a letter for Emma that suggests her husband was killed. But both Iris and Frankie tiptoe around the issue of the doctor's death until a telegram comes officially bearing the bad news. The end.

As I said, it's a plot tortured from the surroundings, entirely artificial and fairly tedious to get through. After finishing the book, I felt cheated out of a good story. The backdrop of WWII is so inherently dramatic that intrigue, suspense and emotion should ooze out of a story like this. Instead, Blake takes a fascinating backdrop and clogs it with the tale of a housewife sitting at home, twiddling her thumbs, waiting for news. If I wanted to read about bored, pregnant ladies irrationally bitter that their husbands are at work, I'd write an autobiography.

The story awkwardly jumps from wartime Europe to an America gearing up for war and the rest of the plot isn't strong enough to prevent the whiplash from that transition. The characters aren't particularly compelling or well developed. Blake has potential to be a great writer. This attempt fell far short of great and it's doomed to be forgotten within a year or two.

Cutting For Stone

Abraham Verghese's Cutting for Stone is a physician's wet dream of an epic, a tale of twin brothers raised by doctors in a missionary hospital in Ethiopia. Don't let the dramatic setting dissuade you from picking up this book. It's really a story about passion, shame, ambition and sex and the consequences of actions driven by such intense emotions.

Cutting For Stone opens with a nun and a surgeon who share their denial of a love affair that evolves in the operating theater and is consummated in a fiery lust that produces twin boys, conjoined at the head. The nun dies in childbirth and the father flees to America, unable to come to terms with his inability to save his lover, with the gruesome reality that he was willing and able to kill his children in a desperate bid to save her.

But he doesn't kill the boys. They survive and are adopted by another doctor couple whose love blooms under the stress and strain of parenting twin boys. The story follows the tale of one brother, Marion, as he matures in the politically unstable Ethiopian environment, as he falls in love and his brother crassly fucks the girl of his dreams. That betrayal eventually prompts Marion to leave Ethiopia for the US so he can pursue his dream of becoming a doctor. And while he's in the states, his lover reappears, fucks him and gives him an STD that nearly kills him.

There's an excellent twist in the tale that I won't reveal here that makes the last 150 pages fly by. It's a fabulous read, made more excellent by the time and care Verghese takes in developing his characters and allowing significant moments of their lives to unfold in a patient and deliberate way. The arch of the story is beautifully constructed and expertly executed to maximize reading pleasure. This is one of the best books I've read in a very long time.

I highly recommend it.

Sunday, March 30, 2008

The Red Badge of Courage

Stephen Crane's serialized novel, The Red Badge of Courage (Simon & Schuster Enriched Classic) may have pleased audiences in 1894, but this crapfest was painful to read and it's current popularity stands as a testament to how high school teachers must enjoy torturing students with horrible books. Crane, a reporter who never fought in the Civil War, chronicles the psychological melodramas of a young soldier, Henry, exposed to the horrors of war for the first time. Henry the intellectual douchebag justifies his cowardly retreat from his first battle as indicative of his superior intelligence--he wanted to preserve his life while his automaton comrades fought like beasts or cogs in the great war machine. Eventually, Henry learns how to fight as a beast as well.

Yawn.

I wouldn't read this bung ever again. And I certainly would never recommend it to anyone. But I did get it for $.10 at a Friends of the Library book sale and despite my loathing of the work itself, I remain entirely enamored of used book sales. There's a certain allure to tattered books that have been passed around for years, their pages yellowed and weathered with use.

Gulliver's Travels

I'm a few books behind in my reviews, so I'm afraid these may be rather abbreviated.

Jonathan's Swift's classic novel, Gulliver's Travels (Collector's Library), available for free here, chronicles the adventures of Gulliver as he travels about the globe. The tales should be familiar to most English-speaking people because, unless you grew up in a bubble, you've heard references to the Lilliputians and other aspects of Gulliver's travels. In picking up some older classic literature, I can see gaps in my education where I feel like I should have been exposed to these stories at some point and for whatever reason, I had to read crap like Where the Red Fern Grows or Flowers for Algernon instead of more foundational literature. Such is life with a crappy education system.

Anyway, Swift breaks Gulliver's travels into four journeys. The first lands him among the Lilliputians, tiny people who imprison him despite their stature. The second lands him among giants where he's carried about in a luxurious box as a kind of curiosity item in a way that brought to mind Paris Hilton's purse dogs. His third adventure brings him to a floating island with inhabitants that beat on each other to get each other's attention, an action I've been inspired to reproduce on my hubby when he zones out on the NCAA tournament or his blog. And last but not least, Gulliver's last trip takes him to a land of noble horses who rule with such integrity and honor that Gulliver is disgusted and depressed to return to humanity.

The text is a goldmine of ideas on various topics from how to rule to the nature of medicine or the law. My interest was piqued by Swift's descriptions of the nature and causes of various illnesses, which included his character's understanding that some people are born with maladies already upon them--an understanding of genetics without the modern frame of reference.

Would I recommend Gulliver's Travels? If you have a tolerance for political science and policy discussions in your literature, you'll enjoy it. It's not an edge-of-your-seat suspense thrill ride, but it's a slow, thoughtful journey that's interesting for what it can say to the modern reader.

Monday, March 24, 2008

The Black Sheep

Honoré de Balzac's famous tale, The Black Sheep (Penguin Classics) seemed to me to lose something in its translation from French to English, as though the original text was populated by subtle plays on words and innuendoes that were simply lost, er, in translation. Ugh. Sorry about that.

It's a gorgeous web Balzac weaves though. The plot is delicious. And here it is, in short form.

One father sires two children. He believes the second, a daughter, to be the product of his wife's infidelity and sends the ill-begotten spawn away. His first child, a son, is a dunce. The father dies and leaves his idiot son a fortune. Meanwhile, his daughter has two sons of her own: her first son is an ambitious, evil bastard and her second son is a pure-hearted artist. Her first son is her true love but even she realizes his true nature after he steals money and is generally a petty, selfish dickhead.

But that's the thing about petty, selfish dickheads. They're predictable. And Balzac counts on it.

The daughter, realizing that she's in a tight financial spot because of her son's dickheadedness decides to call on her dunce brother for a piece of the family fortune. But, her dunce of a brother is being swindled from within his own home, having fallen in love with a peasant girl. The girl is in love with a rogue from town who wants to take the dunce's fortune and is set to do exactly that. The rogue is far too clever for the daughter and her good son who fall prey to his manipulations and leave town penniless and shamed.

But the daughter's dickheaded son is just the match for the rogue. He finds himself in a position to take on the girl and the rogue and he uses his innate dickheadedness to win the day, to swindle the swindler. This is the brilliance of Balzac's plot. He uses an evil character to screw over another evil character and it's fabulous!

So the dickheaded son screws over the girl and her rogue. He gets the fortune. And then he's done in by his own dickheadedness and the fortune falls to the daughter's good son, the pure-hearted artist that Balzac clearly wanted us to adore from the start. So the plot comes full circle, good people are rewarded and evil plays its part in bringing about a happy ending.

It took me a good 150 pages to warm up to the plot but once I realized what Balzac was doing, I was enthralled. It's slow and plodding. You need patience to get into it and even then, the idea of the plot may be better than the actual application.

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Robinson Crusoe

Widely regarded as the first English novel, Robinson Crusoe (Collector's Library) is now one of a number of works of classic literature available for free on the web. Ah, the irony.

Stylistically, this book leaves a lot to be desired. It's plot is plodding and repetitive and repetitive, there's no thrilling climax and the ending seems oddly out of place. The language and moralistic overtones make this a challenging read that most people would probably pass up in favor of some Tom Clancy novel. Sigh.

Defoe tells the story of an ill-fated soldier who sets sail from Britain against his father's advice only to have a series of adventures before ending up shipwrecked alone on a deserted island. Sound familiar? Dozens of crappier authors have taken Daniel Defoe's novel idea and come up with a bastardized version. But this, darlings, is the original, the genesis, the inspiration.

And it's entertaining, after you come to terms with the fact that Defoe is writing to an audience that assumes that Christianity is the Best Religion Ever and that slavery is part of the natural order of life. It's the origin of some of that folk wisdom that's become cliche, like the only thing we have to fear is fear itself or it's better to look on the sunny side of life. For some reason, I thought that was insanely cool, even though I'm sure Defoe probably ripped that stuff off from some other author I haven't read yet.

But uh, what is the deal with the wolves? I must have missed the hidden message revealing why Defoe included Crusoe's canine encounter. I assumed that it was there to show the whimsy of fate--like here's the schmuck who survived 26 years on a deserted island and now he's going to be devoured by wolves in France. HA! Or not. Thoughts on that?

At any rate, Robinson Crusoe isn't for everyone. But it is the original shipwreck story, so if you're into that kind of thing and you have the patience and tenacity to stick with the thick language until you get accustomed to it, it's worth reading. Entertaining and educational, but it's not for everyone.